Prioritize Conversions in your Local SEO Page Updates

Mike Roberts
December 16, 2025
8 min read
Table of Contents

Local SEO changed fast over the last year. AI Overviews are answering questions before users ever reach your site, and when they do click through, the bar for convincing them to act is higher than it’s ever been.

That’s the challenge I want to talk about here: local service pages aren’t just meant to rank. They’re meant to convert. And historically, those two goals haven’t always played nicely together.

This is exactly why we just shipped a major RivalFlow improvement for local businesses.

Why Local Service Pages Are Hard to Optimize

Local service landing pages are different from blog posts or informational content. They’re persuasive by design. Their job is to turn a visitor into a caller, a form fill, or a booked appointment.

That’s what made them one of the hardest page types to improve with RivalFlow. Not just that, we flat out did not want to ruin any conversion mojo you might have had in place.

If you blindly insert competitor questions and answers into the middle of a local landing page, you risk breaking the conversion flow. The page gets longer, messier, and less focused. You might gain SEO points while quietly losing revenue.

That’s not a trade-off anyone wants.

At the same time, AI Overviews changed the rules.

We’re seeing less traffic overall, which means every click matters more. When someone does land on your page, more of those browsers need to become buyers.

So the real challenge became clear:
We don’t just need to teach search engines what you do.
We need to teach AIs how to sell your service.

Teaching AI How to Sell Your Service

When we looked at failed or underperforming local pages, the biggest issues weren’t buried deep in the content. They were often right at the top of the page.

In one example, the page had no clear call to action above the fold. No phone number. No obvious next step. Just a missed opportunity staring back at us.

That led to a shift in how RivalFlow approaches local service pages.

We introduced a new section called Overall Improvements. Instead of jumping straight into gap-closing questions and answers, we first evaluate the conversion block itself.

Is it good enough?
Does it clearly tell visitors what to do next?
Does it reflect local SEO best practices?

If the answer is no, RivalFlow now rewrites that top-of-page experience before touching anything else.

What the New Local SEO Upgrade Actually Changes

In the roofing company example from the video, we kept what was already working. The headline and H1 stayed intact because they were strong.

Then we rebuilt what was missing.

We added clear CTAs above the scroll, including the company’s real phone number and a “request a free roofing quote” option that stays visible as you scroll.

We grounded the content in the real world. Specific Toronto neighborhoods. Harsh Canadian winters. Emergency roof repairs. Transparent pricing. Five-star reviews from platforms where they actually earned them.

The page stopped sounding generic and started sounding local, credible, and trustworthy.

As I said in the video:

“The biggest opportunity here isn't necessarily these questions and answers. It's about improving the page overall and causing more of their browsers to become customers.”

We even reinforced urgency with a second call to action: act now, because Toronto weather changes fast and roof damage doesn’t wait.

All of this does double duty. It improves conversion rate optimization and strengthens local SEO signals at the same time.

Closing SEO Gaps Without Breaking Conversions

In addition to all of this--we're still closing SEO gaps. It’s how pages move up in the SERPs and show up in AI Overviews.

We just pulled from conversion-building best practices to change where some of those elements go on the page.

Instead of clobbering primary conversion sections, RivalFlow now pushes gap-closing content into smarter locations. In this case, the page already had an FAQ section, which is perfect for local service pages.

That’s where competitor questions and answers go.

✅ You get the SEO benefit.
✅ You get the AI visibility.
✅ And you don’t sacrifice the flow that turns visitors into customers.

And as usual, the green highlights in RivalFlow make it easy to see exactly what’s been added and why.

Why This Is a Big Deal for Agencies and Local Businesses

If you manage local service businesses—especially as an agency—this upgrade changes the game.

Even if you ignored gap closing entirely, the automated rewrites alone would be a win. Choosing the right entities, emphasizing real differentiators, and improving above-the-fold CTAs can dramatically improve performance.

But when you combine that with smart gap placement, you get pages that rank better, convert better, and teach AI systems how to understand and recommend your service.

It’s one of those rare cases where SEO, CRO, and AI optimization actually align.

That’s why we’re so excited about this release—and why I think it’s going to make a real difference for local businesses navigating AI-driven search.